We demonstrate how neural networks can drive mathematical discovery through a case study of the Hadwiger-Nelson problem, a long-standing open problem from discrete geometry and combinatorics about coloring the plane avoiding monochromatic unit-distance pairs. Using neural networks as approximators, we reformulate this mixed discrete-continuous geometric coloring problem as an optimization task with a probabilistic, differentiable loss function. This enables gradient-based exploration of admissible configurations that most significantly led to the discovery of two novel six-colorings, providing the first improvements in thirty years to the off-diagonal variant of the original problem (Anonymous, 2024). Here, we establish the underlying machine learning approach used to obtain these results and demonstrate its broader applicability through additional results and numerical insights.